Carter & Cavero, a Sea Girt, NJ | Monmouth County, NJ-based Gourmet Foods Store, offers unique Mediterranean foods | Mediterranean flavors from Europe, including the best Extra Virgin Olive Oils, Polyphenol Rich Olive Oils, Balsamic Vinegars, and so much more in store and/or via mail order.
OLIVE OILS
-
Always a favorite, our Meyer Lemon olive oil has the light refreshing flavor of Meyer Lemon (a cross between a lemon and an orange which is sweeter and less bitter than regular lemons). Suggested Pairings: -
Our Tuscan Herb Infused EVOO is a favorite amongst chefs, staff, and customers alike. This is the highest quality, true-to-herb flavor olive oil available. The natural herb oil extracts and hint of fresh garlic have been combined with a fresh, super premium extra virgin olive oil base to create an inspired olive oil of the highest culinary standard. Top notes of dried basil, marjoram, garlic, oregano, thyme, rosemary, and crushed red pepper create a flavor explosion that is both balanced and harmonious. This classic infused olive oil is great for everyday use! 🍃✨Delicious Ways to Enjoy:
🍃 Drizzle over fresh salads, grilled veggies, or pasta for an invigorating herbal lift.
🍃 Enhance roasted meats or seafood with a sophisticated, aromatic finish.
🍃 Blend into dressings or vinaigrettes for an irresistible burst of Tuscan flavor.
🍃 Dip artisan bread into a drizzle of our olive oil and a sprinkle of sea salt for a rustic snack.
🍃 Use as a marinade to infuse your favorite proteins with authentic Italian flair.
🍃 Stir into soups or stews for a rich, herb-infused complexity.A Taste of Tuscany in Every Drop! Whether you’re dressing up a simple salad or creating a gourmet masterpiece, Carter & Cavero’s Tuscan Herb Olive Oil is a must-have for your kitchen.
🛒 Order now and bring the authentic taste of Tuscany to your table! 🍃✨
-
Bold, aromatic, and full of rich flavor, Carter & Cavero’s Garlic Olive Oil is a pantry essential for garlic lovers and gourmet home cooks. Made with premium extra virgin olive oil and infused with the robust flavor of fresh garlic, this oil adds a savory depth to a wide variety of dishes. 🧄🫒✨Delicious Ways to Enjoy:
🧄 Sauté vegetables, shrimp, or chicken for rich, garlicky flavor.
🧄 Drizzle over roasted potatoes, grilled veggies, or pizza.
🧄 Use as a base for pasta sauces, risottos, or soups.
🧄 Blend with balsamic vinegar for an easy, flavorful vinaigrette.
🧄 Use as a dip for fresh bread with a pinch of sea salt or herbs.
🧄 Brush on meats or veggies before grilling for a bold finish.Elevate Every Dish with Garlic Goodness! Whether you're cooking up a hearty meal or looking to add depth to a simple side dish, Carter & Cavero’s Garlic Olive Oil is the perfect way to infuse your recipes with bold, savory flavor.
🛒 Order now and bring the rich taste of garlic to your kitchen! 🧄✨
-
This extra virgin olive oil is cold-extracted from 100% Nocellara del Belice variety olives hand-harvested in Western Sicily. This medium intensity oil has aromas of freshly-picked tomatoes and vegetables with a mildly bitter and spicy finish. It is perfect for salmon carpaccio, pasta with tomato sauce, grilled white meats and fish. -
Fresh, fragrant, and full of flavor, Carter & Cavero’s Basil Olive Oil captures the essence of fresh-picked basil blended with premium extra virgin olive oil. This aromatic oil brings a touch of the Mediterranean to your kitchen, perfect for adding herbal brightness to your favorite dishes. 🌿🫒✨Delicious Ways to Enjoy:
🌿 Drizzle over tomatoes and mozzarella for a quick caprese salad.
🌿 Toss with pasta, gnocchi, or risotto for a fragrant finish.
🌿 Brush on grilled vegetables, chicken, or seafood.
🌿 Use as a dipping oil for bread with a sprinkle of sea salt.
🌿 Mix with balsamic for a delicious vinaigrette.
🌿 Add to homemade pesto, marinades, or sauces for extra depth.A Taste of the Garden in Every Drop! Whether you're crafting a classic Italian dish or just elevating everyday meals, Carter & Cavero’s Basil Olive Oil delivers fresh, herbaceous flavor that’s as versatile as it is delicious.
🛒 Order now and bring a burst of basil to your kitchen! 🌿✨
VINEGARS
-
Elevate your culinary experience with Carter & Cavero’s Traditional Balsamic Vinegar. Made from high-quality aged grape must, this balsamic vinegar boasts a rich, velvety texture and a perfectly balanced sweet-tart flavor. Its deep, complex notes make it a versatile staple in any kitchen.
Uses:
✔️ Drizzle over fresh salads and roasted vegetables
✔️ Enhance meats, seafood, and marinades
✔️ Pair with cheeses, fruits, and artisan bread
✔️ Create gourmet glazes and reductionsCrafted with tradition, this balsamic vinegar is a must-have for food lovers seeking exceptional taste and quality. Add a bottle to your pantry today!
-
Indulge in the luscious sweetness of Italian Fig Balsamic Vinegar, a perfect blend of rich, aged balsamic infused with the natural essence of ripe Italian figs. This gourmet vinegar offers a deep, fruity flavor with a smooth, velvety finish that enhances both sweet and savory dishes.
Suggested Uses:
✔️ Drizzle over fresh salads, roasted vegetables, and cheese boards
✔️ Pair with meats, poultry, and seafood for a gourmet glaze
✔️ Mix into marinades, dressings, and sauces for a hint of natural sweetness
✔️ Elevate desserts like vanilla ice cream, yogurt, or fruit compotesA pantry essential for food lovers and home chefs, this fig-infused balsamic will add a touch of Mediterranean luxury to every meal!
-
Our Best-Selling Sicilian Lemon White Balsamic Vinegar. Bright, zesty, and irresistibly smooth, Sicilian Lemon White Balsamic Vinegar from Carter & Cavero captures the sun-kissed essence of Sicily in every drop! Made with aged white balsamic vinegar and infused with the vibrant citrus flavor of fresh Sicilian lemons, this refreshing balsamic is perfect for adding a touch of sweet-tart elegance to your favorite dishes. 🍋✨Delicious Ways to Enjoy:
🍋 Drizzle over fresh salads, grilled vegetables, or roasted asparagus.
🍋 Glaze seafood, chicken, or shrimp for a burst of citrusy flavor.
🍋 Blend into marinades for a fresh, tangy kick.
🍋 Stir into sparkling water or cocktails for a unique twist.
🍋 Pair with olive oil for a zesty vinaigrette.
🍋 Drizzle over fresh fruit, yogurt, or desserts for a light, sweet finish.A Taste of the Mediterranean! Light, crisp, and incredibly versatile, Carter & Cavero’s Sicilian Lemon White Balsamic Vinegar adds a vibrant citrus touch to both savory and sweet dishes, making it a must-have for your kitchen.
🛒 Order now and bring the flavors of Sicily to your table! 🍋✨
-
Light, crisp, and elegantly smooth, White Balsamic Vinegar from Carter & Cavero offers a delicate balance of sweetness and tanginess. Made from premium white Trebbiano grapes, this aged balsamic is less intense than traditional dark balsamic, making it a versatile staple in any kitchen. Its mild acidity and subtly sweet flavor make it perfect for enhancing a wide range of dishes without overpowering them. ✨🍶Delicious Ways to Enjoy:
🍶 Drizzle over leafy greens, caprese salads, or roasted vegetables.
🍶 Blend into vinaigrettes and dressings for a light, tangy flavor.
🍶 Use as a marinade for seafood, poultry, or pork.
🍶 Mix into sparkling water or cocktails for a refreshing twist.
🍶 Pair with fresh fruit, yogurt, or cheeses for a naturally sweet touch.
🍶 Combine with olive oil for the perfect bread dipping sauce.A Kitchen Essential for Everyday Cooking! Whether you're crafting gourmet meals or simple, everyday dishes, Carter & Cavero’s White Balsamic Vinegar brings a delicate and refined acidity that enhances every bite.
🛒 Order now and elevate your culinary creations with white balsamic! ✨🍶
-
Experience the vibrant, fruity essence of Raspberry Balsamic Vinegar, a rich and tangy blend of aged balsamic infused with the bold sweetness of ripe raspberries. This versatile gourmet vinegar enhances both savory and sweet dishes, adding depth and complexity to your favorite recipes.
Suggested Uses:
✔️ Drizzle over fresh greens, roasted vegetables, or caprese salad
✔️ Glaze meats like chicken, pork, or duck for a sweet-tart finish
✔️ Mix into vinaigrettes, marinades, and reduction sauces
✔️ Elevate desserts like cheesecake, chocolate brownies, or fresh berriesA pantry essential for food enthusiasts, this berry-infused balsamic is the perfect way to add a touch of sweet sophistication to any dish!
GOURMET FOOD
-
Elevate your dishes with Carter & Cavero’s Pesto Parmesan spice blend! This rich and savory mix combines the nutty depth of Parmesan cheese with the fragrant, herbaceous notes of basil and garlic, bringing the classic flavors of pesto to your kitchen. Perfect for mixing with olive oil as a flavorful bread dip, it also enhances pasta, risottos, roasted vegetables, and grilled meats. Whether you're creating an Italian-inspired feast or adding a gourmet touch to everyday meals, this versatile blend is a must-have. Savor the taste of Italy in every bite! 🧀🌿✨ Suggested Uses:- Add to EVOO for bread dipping!
- Stir into butter or cream cheese for a flavorful spread!
- Sprinkle over pasta dishes like fettuccine alfredo, pesto pasta, or carbonara
- Mix into creamy sauces for an extra Parmesan kick.
- Stir into mashed potatoes for a cheesy, garlicky upgrade.
- Sprinkle over Caesar salad, caprese, or mixed greens.
-
A rich and creamy treat that is as classic as it is craveable. Ways to Enjoy:- Tossed with greens, dried cranberries and balsamic
- Panko-fry them and pop away.
- Jazz up your charcuterie spread!
SALE
-
Bright, citrusy, and beautifully aromatic, Carter & Cavero’s Blood Orange Olive Oil is a stunning fusion of premium extra virgin olive oil and the sweet, tangy essence of ripe blood oranges. This flavorful oil brings a refreshing twist to both sweet and savory dishes, adding zesty depth and Mediterranean flair to every bite. 🍊🫒✨Delicious Ways to Enjoy:
🍊 Drizzle over roasted beets, carrots, or Brussels sprouts.
🍊 Use in salad dressings, especially with arugula, spinach, or fennel.
🍊 Marinate chicken, shrimp, or salmon for a bright, citrusy flavor.
🍊 Substitute for butter or oil in baked goods like muffins, cakes, or brownies.
🍊 Pair with balsamic for a refreshing bread dip or vinaigrette.
🍊 Splash over grain bowls, couscous, or wild rice for a zesty touch.Citrus-Infused Elegance in Every Drop! Whether you're crafting a fresh summer salad, glazing seafood, or adding depth to baked goods, Carter & Cavero’s Blood Orange Olive Oil brings sunny, citrus-infused flavor to your kitchen creations.
🛒 Order now and enjoy the bright, bold taste of blood orange in every dish! 🍊✨
-
Experience the perfect balance of sweet and tangy with Strawberry Balsamic Vinegar from Carter & Cavero. Crafted from aged Italian balsamic and infused with the luscious essence of ripe strawberries, this versatile vinegar adds a delightful fruity twist to both savory and sweet dishes. 🍓✨ Suggested Uses: 🍓 Drizzle over mixed greens with goat cheese, nuts, and fresh berries.
🍓 Use as a glaze for grilled chicken, pork, or salmon.
🍓 Add to marinades or vinaigrettes for a fruity depth of flavor.
🍓 Enhance cheese boards with a splash over brie or blue cheese.
🍓 Pair with vanilla ice cream, yogurt, or fresh fruit for a gourmet dessert.Whether you're creating a summer salad or adding a sweet balsamic reduction to your favorite dish, Carter & Cavero’s Strawberry Balsamic Vinegar brings a vibrant, sophisticated touch to every meal.
🛒 Order now and elevate your kitchen creations with this fruity, flavorful balsamic!
GIFTS
-
EASY TO USE: 1. PEEL: Place the garlic clove in peeler and roll to remove skin. 2. GRATE: Add a drop of water, olive oil or lemon and rub ingredients. 3. BRUSH: Add the paste to recipes or use as a dipping dish. MULTI-PURPOSE: Finely grate garlic, ginger, nutmeg, parmesan, citrus zest, and more, into a fine purée unlocking the full flavor. Ideal for making sauces, dips, marinades, and gravies. DISHWASHER SAFE & DURABLE: Handmade with premium, lead-free ceramic, this plate is designed to last. It is dishwasher safe, ensuring easy cleanup. HAND-CRAFTED: Each grater is hand-painted and unique. Colors and designs may vary from the original picture. Size: 5 inch diameter. -
Small in size but big in flavor, Carter & Cavero’s Mini Dipper Gift Set is the perfect introduction to our world of olive oils and vinegars. Thoughtfully packaged and beautifully presented, this mini set makes a charming gift for any foodie, host, or olive oil lover who enjoys the simple pleasure of dipping fresh bread in gourmet oil and balsamic.
Gift Set Includes:
- 100mL Olive Oil – Choose from our smooth, cold-pressed Extra Virgin Olive Oil or a flavor-infused favorite like Garlic, Basil, or Lemon.
- 100mL Balsamic Vinegar – A perfectly paired complement, available in our signature Traditional Balsamic or a bright, fruity variety.
- Small Jar of Bread Dipping Spices – A savory blend of Mediterranean herbs and spices designed to enhance every dip.
- Stoneware Dipping Dish – Elegant, durable, and just the right size for serving your oil and vinegar in style.
A Little Taste of the Mediterranean! Whether it’s a thoughtful thank-you, a hostess gift, or a flavorful treat for yourself, The Mini Dipper Gift Set brings together gourmet simplicity and Carter & Cavero quality — in the most delightful way.
🛒 Order now and dip into delicious flavor — the perfect small gift with big taste! ✨
-
Elegant, rich, and perfectly balanced, Carter & Cavero’s Balsamic Trio Gift Set is a curated selection of three of our finest balsamic vinegars — each offering its own unique flavor profile and endless culinary possibilities. Beautifully packaged and ready to gift, this trio is a must-have for anyone who loves the art of fine dining and entertaining.
Basket Includes:
- Traditional Balsamic Vinegar – Deep, smooth, and complex, this aged classic is perfect for salads, marinades, and drizzling over grilled meats or cheese.
- Sicilian Lemon White Balsamic Vinegar – Bright and citrusy with a hint of sweetness, it pairs beautifully with seafood, fresh greens, and desserts.
- Fig Balsamic Vinegar – Sweet and velvety with the natural richness of ripe figs, ideal for cheese boards, roasted vegetables, and glazes.
A Taste of Sophistication in Every Drop! From the deep richness of Traditional Balsamic to the bright zest of Sicilian Lemon and the sweet elegance of Fig, The Balsamic Trio brings together the best of Carter & Cavero’s artisan craftsmanship.
🛒 Order now and elevate every meal with the art of balsamic perfection! 🍇✨
-
When you pair our delicious flavored olive oils with our rich & decadent balsamic vinegars , it is a healthy way to bring vibrant & fresh exciting & exotic flavored to your table. This gives you endless combinations and varieties to dress up any meal you are planning, you will never buy store salad dressing again! Let the adventures begin! -
Discover a delicious tasting experience with the Sutter Buttes Gourmet Jam Gift Pack, featuring four artisan-crafted 2 oz mini jams made with premium fruits, real ingredients, and rich, vibrant flavors. Beautifully packaged and perfect for gifting, this set offers a delightful variety that pairs wonderfully with breakfast favorites, cheese boards, desserts, and more.
Includes:
🍓 Strawberry Vanilla Jam – Sweet, bright strawberries blended with warm vanilla for a smooth, comforting flavor.
🍑 Peach Bourbon Jam – Ripe peaches with a hint of bourbon create a rich, Southern-inspired treat.
🍷 Merlot Wine Jam – Deep, sophisticated notes of Merlot wine infused with luscious fruit for a gourmet finish.
🥭 Pineapple Mango Jam – Tropical, tangy, and refreshing — a sunny burst of pineapple and mango in every spoonful.Serving Suggestions:
✨ Spread on toast, muffins, or warm biscuits
✨ Pair with cheeses, charcuterie boards, or crostini
✨ Swirl into yogurt, oatmeal, or desserts
✨ Use as a glaze for meats, poultry, or roasted vegetablesA Sweet & Savory Gift for Every Food Lover! Whether you're treating yourself or surprising someone special, the Sutter Buttes Gourmet Jam Gift Pack delivers exceptional flavor and artisanal craftsmanship in every bite.
🛒 Shop now and enjoy four delicious jams in one beautiful set! 🍓✨
