Olive Oil2025-04-23T15:44:47-04:00

Carter & Cavero, a Sea Girt, NJ | Monmouth County, NJ Gourmet Foods Store, offers Mediterranean foods | Mediterranean flavors from Europe, including the best Extra Virgin Olive Oils, as well as Polyphenol Rich Olive Oils in store and/or via mail order on this website.

Olive Oil

  • Lemon Pepper Olive Oil – NEW!

    Price range: $12.95 through $38.95
    This may be one of our most versatile infused olive oils yet! Bright, zesty, and perfectly spiced, Carter & Cavero’s Lemon Pepper Olive Oil combines the fresh citrus flavor of lemon with the warm bite of cracked black pepper in a smooth extra virgin olive oil base. Yes, the pepper is not a flavoring, but actual, freshly ground black pepper, so this oil does have sediment. This vibrant infusion adds a refreshing kick and gourmet flair to everyday cooking.

    Delicious Ways to Enjoy:

    🍋 Drizzle over grilled chicken, seafood, or roasted vegetables.
    🍋 Use in vinaigrettes or pasta salads for a tangy twist.
    🍋 Brush on pizza dough or flatbreads before baking.
    🍋 Toss with potatoes, asparagus, or broccoli for bright, peppery depth.
    🍋 Splash into soups, marinades, or risotto for added zest.

    A Bright Kick of Flavor in Every Drop! Whether you’re grilling, roasting, or finishing a dish, Carter & Cavero’s Lemon Pepper Olive Oil adds the perfect balance of citrus and spice to your meals.

    🛒 Shop now and spice up your kitchen with Lemon Pepper Olive Oil!

  • Cobrançosa Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Portugal

    Price range: $14.95 through $46.95
    A medium intensity oil with low bitterness, strong pungency, and moderate fruitiness.  It is quite complex, with several ripe, fruity flavors of butter, nuttiness, and apple – plus some bright, spicy, herbaceous flavors of mint, cinnamon, and chili pepper, especially green apple and black pepper.  It is very nicely balanced and relatively fresh tasting.
  • Kosterina Organic EVERYDAY EVOO is your new go-to for cooking, baking, roasting and grilling – anytime heat is applied! Crafted with cooks in mind, the Everyday has a mild, fruity flavor with a smooth finish that will not overpower your food. This oil stands up to heat beautifully and is able to maintain its flavor with a smoke point of over 400° F. Production Area: Crete, Greece Producer: Kosterina Intensity: Mild Acidity (%): 0.38 Polyphenols: 663 Varietal: Koroneiki Pairs Best With:
    • Leafy Green Salads
    • Grilled Fish + White Meat
    • Breads
    • Pasta
  • Pizzaiolo Olive Oil

    Price range: $12.95 through $38.95
    A blend of sun-dried tomato, oregano, garlic and spicy peppers finished with a dash of lemon. A perfect compliment to any pizza sauce! Suggested Pairings:
  • Roasted Onion Olive Oil

    Price range: $12.95 through $38.95
    Our Roasted Onion flavored olive oil is truly a culinary delight. It's aroma is incredibly fragrant, with a rich, robust, and savory flavor. The Roasted Onion infusion brings a unique depth and complexity to the oil, making it the perfect secret ingredient for all your favorite recipes. Suggested Pairings:  
  • Peperoncino & Garlic Agrumato Olive Oil

    Price range: $12.95 through $38.95
    A perfect harmony of hot red peppers and Italian garlic! The flavor has the heat that you all have been asking for; an immediate zing of hot pepper that builds and lingers, with a pleasant but not too intense garlic flavor. Suggested Pairings:
  • Dill Olive Oil

    Price range: $12.95 through $38.95
    Wonderfully fragrant, bright, and delightful, this infused extra virgin olive oil tastes just like the fresh herb. It’s deep, almost anise-like flavor is pleasantly savory. Suggested Pairings:
  • Cilantro & Red Onion Olive OIl

    Price range: $12.95 through $38.95
    A nice balance of astringent and sweet, our cilantro & red onion infused olive oil has a very fresh depth of flavor. Its herbaceous piquant notes translate to a perfect olive oil for Latin, Asian and Middle Eastern dishes. Suggested Pairings:
  • Pesto Olive Oil

    Price range: $12.95 through $38.95
    Our Pesto Olive Oil is jam packed with the flavors of fresh basil, parmesan cheese, and a touch of garlic. Carter & Cavero is dedicated to searching out quality products that surprise the senses, that make people say, “Wow” when they smell, taste or see them. We hope our customers will cherish what they find here not only because of their fine taste or beauty, but also because of the incredible skill and artistry that has gone into their creation. *Vegan and allergen free! Suggested Pairings:  
  • Porcini Mushroom and Sage Olive Oil

    Price range: $12.95 through $38.95
    Imagine delicate, round, and savory porcini mushrooms touched with a dash of freshly picked sage.  Our Porcini Mushroom and Sage olive oil begins with a soft and delicate porcini flavor that is balanced by just enough fresh sage to give it an earthy and smooth aroma. This olive oil truly captures all the wonderful flavors that come with cooking with mushrooms. Suggested Pairings:
  • Butter Olive Oil

    Price range: $12.95 through $38.95

    Butter Olive Oil 🧈🫒✨

    Creamy, smooth, and delightfully rich, Carter & Cavero’s Butter Olive Oil offers the delicious taste of butter—with none of the dairy! Made with premium extra virgin olive oil and infused with natural buttery flavor, this versatile oil is perfect for those seeking a healthier, plant-based alternative to traditional butter without sacrificing taste.🧈🫒✨

    Delicious Ways to Enjoy:

    🧈 Use for sautéing vegetables, eggs, or seafood.
    🧈 Drizzle over popcorn for a buttery snack without the guilt.
    🧈 Toss with pasta, rice, or steamed veggies for added richness.
    🧈 Bake with it as a butter substitute in muffins, cookies, or cakes.
    🧈 Spread on toast or pancakes for a dairy-free morning treat.
    🧈 Blend with garlic or herbs for a quick, flavorful finishing oil.

    All the Butter Flavor, None of the Dairy! Perfect for everyday cooking, baking, and finishing, Carter & Cavero’s Butter Olive Oil brings indulgent flavor and versatility to your kitchen—without the cholesterol or dairy.

    🛒 Order now and enjoy the rich taste of butter in a healthier, plant-based way! 🧈✨

  • Bacon Olive Oil

    Price range: $12.95 through $38.95

    Bacon Olive Oil 🥓🫒✨

    Rich, savory, and irresistibly smoky, Carter & Cavero’s Bacon Olive Oil is the ultimate flavor boost for bacon lovers! Infused with the robust essence of smoky bacon and blended with premium extra virgin olive oil, this bold and mouthwatering oil brings bacon flavor to your favorite dishes—without the sizzle or mess. 🥓🫒✨

    Delicious Ways to Enjoy:

    🥓 Drizzle over roasted Brussels sprouts, potatoes, or green beans.
    🥓 Use to fry or scramble eggs for a bacon-flavored breakfast.
    🥓 Brush on grilled meats, burgers, or chicken.
    🥓 Toss with popcorn or drizzle over mac & cheese for a savory snack.
    🥓 Blend into vinaigrettes or aioli for smoky depth.
    🥓 Pair with maple balsamic for a sweet-and-savory glaze or dressing.

    Bacon Lovers, Rejoice! Whether you're enhancing vegetables, topping off breakfast dishes, or adding rich flavor to everyday recipes, Carter & Cavero’s Bacon Olive Oil delivers smoky, savory goodness in every drop.

    🛒 Order now and enjoy the flavor of bacon—anytime, anywhere! 🥓✨

Go to Top